Monday 7 May 2012

Tragedy


The 5th Quarter (2011)

Based on real events this film from writer/director Rick Bieber stars Ryan Merriman, Aidan Quinn and Andie MacDowell. A family loses their youngest son in a car crash while the eldest son plays college football.

Films based on real life tragedies need to be dealt with sensitively but this film is anything but sensitive and just goes for over the top sentimentality in place of any real content. From a narrative point of view the film struggles to decide if it is a college football film or a family tragedy film and so ends up being really unclear on the story it is telling. At best this is a TV issue of the week film which is a shame as it ends up trivialising what is no doubt some series issues.

2/5

No comments:

Post a Comment